Collector-owned singles · Graded & raw

Pullsomethingdamn good.

Thousands of graded and raw singles across every sport and TCG, consigned by real collectors. Every card ships sleeved, top-loaded and tracked.

Shop singlesSell your cards
NEW DROPS WEEKLY

Shop by category

View all
01 Baseball 02 Football 03 Basketball 04 Pop Culture 05 TCG
JUST LISTED

Fresh singles

RIP IT OR SIT ON IT

Sealed wax

Shop all sealed

More than a shop

PSA · BECKETT · SGC

Grading, handled

We flag the cards worth grading, you approve, and we prep, submit, track and list the slabs. Whatever you want to keep we can store or ship to you. Different fees apply for different tiers and grading companies.How grading works
SAFE KEEPING

Stored with care

Your cards stay sleeved, cataloged and stored until they sell. If you want to store your personal collection we have different options. We are fully insured with 24/7 surveillance and overnight onsite security.Consignment FAQ
SHIPPED SAFE

Packed right

Penny sleeve, top loader, team bag, bubble mailer. Tracking on every order, insurance on every card to protect against shipping issues. Especially on high-value cards.Shipping info
HIGH-END CARDS

Premium auctions

Your biggest cards can go to auction on Fanatics Collect, where serious high-end buyers bid. We can use other platforms as requested. This is your collection and you are in control of what happens to it.Premium auctions
CONSIGN WITH DAMN CARD SHOP

6–10% The bigger the card, the lower the fee.

CARD SELLS FOROUR FEE
$100 – $49910%
$500 – $4,9998%
$5,000+6%

Send us your collection. We store it, grade the big ones, photograph, list, sell and ship. You keep 90–94% of every sale. No listing fees, no storage fees, no monthly fees.

Start a consignmentConsignment FAQ
  1. Send it in Tell us what you have, then ship your collection with the tracked, insured label we send you.
  2. We sort & grade We catalog every card and pull the ones worth grading. You approve which go to PSA, Beckett or SGC.
  3. We list & sell Real photos and fair pricing. Singles list here; the big ones go to auction on Fanatics Collect.
  4. You get paid Every sale shows up in your statement. You keep 90–94% of the sale price.
INCLUDED IN EVERY CONSIGNMENT
  • Storage
  • Cataloging
  • Photos & listing
  • PSA · Beckett · SGC submissions
  • Pricing
  • Fanatics Collect auction setup
  • Packing & shipping to buyers
  • Buyer support

Grading company fees (PSA, Beckett, SGC) are paid by the consignor. Cards we pull as grading candidates that you choose not to grade: $5 per card inspection fee. Payouts: Within 7-10 days via PayPal, Zelle, wire, other.

CARDS $15 – $100

We'll buy them outright

Cash up front, no waiting for a sale. Based on current market value.Under $15? We'll sell your bulk for you through our network of buyers.
60–80%of market value
Get a cash offer

Buy with confidence

FAST SHIPPING Every order ships within 3 business days, with tracking.
REAL PHOTOS Front and back scans of the exact card you get.
COMBINED SHIPPING Buy more, pay one shipping fee. Insurance on each order.
QUESTIONS? [EMAIL] — replies within [X] hours
Shipping & returns